12/27/2022 0 Comments Reddit delphi murders![]() GPT-3, for example, is consistently Islamophobic, associating Muslims with violence, and pushes gender stereotypes, linking women to ideas of family and men with politics. Other programs of this nature, such as OpenAI’s GPT-3, have been shown to lack common-sense understanding and reflect societal biases found in their training data. It is essentially a large language model - a type of AI system that learns by analyzing vast chunks of text to find statistical regularities. This is not unusual in the world of AI.Īsk Delphi’s problems stem from how it was created. What all this ultimately means is that a) you can coax Ask Delphi into making any moral judgement you like through careful wording, because b) the program has no actual human understanding of what is actually being asked of it, and so c) is less about making moral judgements than it is about reflecting the users’ biases back to themselves coated in a veneer of machine objectivity. ![]() The AI will tell you that “having an abortion” is “ okay,” for example, but “aborting a baby” is “ murder.” (If I had to offer an explanation here, I’d guess that this is a byproduct of the fact that the first phrase uses neutral language while the second is more inflammatory and so associated with anti-abortion sentiment.) Other verbal triggers are less obvious, though. Similarly, if you add “ without apologizing” to the end of many benign descriptions, like “ standing still” or “ making pancakes,” it will assume you should have apologized and tells you that you’re being rude. If you add the phrase “if it makes everyone happy” to the end of your statement, then the AI will smile beneficently on any immoral activity of your choice, up to and including genocide. For example, the AI will tell you that “drunk driving” is wrong but that “having a few beers while driving because it hurts no-one” is a-okay. Sometimes it’s obvious how to tip the scales. Even very small changes to how you pose a particular quandary can flip the system’s judgement from condemnation to approval. Most of Ask Delphi’s judgements, though, aren’t so much ethically wrong as they are obviously influenced by their framing. It’s easy to manipulate the AI’s judgements by reframing your question We’ve reached out to the system’s creators to confirm this and will update if we hear back.) This seems to have been disabled after it generated a number of particularly offensive answers. It has clear biases, telling you that America is “ good” and that Somalia is “ dangerous” and it’s amenable to special pleading, noting that eating babies is “okay” as long as you are “really, really hungry.” Worryingly, it approves straightforwardly racist and homophobic statements, saying it’s “ good” to “secure the existence of our people and a future for white children” (a white supremacist slogan known as the 14 words) and that “being straight is more morally acceptable than being gay.” (That last example comes from a feature that allowed users to compare two statements. You can pose any question you like and be sure to receive an answer, wrapped in the authority of the algorithm rather than the soothsayer.Īsk Delphi isn’t impeachable, though: it’s attracting attention mostly because of its many moral missteps and odd judgements. From a more mechanical perspective, the system also offers all the addictive certainty of a Magic 8-Ball. We already have a tendency to frame AI systems in mystical terms - as unknowable entities that tap into higher forms of knowledge - and the presentation of Ask Delphi as a literal oracle encourages such an interpretation. It’s not hard to see why the program has become popular. This is certainly as its creators intended: each answer is provided with a quick link to “share this on Twitter,” an innovation unavailable to the ancient Greeks. Since Ask Delphi launched, its nuggets of wisdom have gone viral in news stories and on social media. Each answer from the AI oracle includes a button to “share this on Twitter”
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |